I wrote this story/journal a number of months ago. I saw it on my computer today after a reformat, and now it kind of amuses me. It’s a long and rambling (and not particularly well written) rant about my ex-girlfriend. It’s kind of interesting to look back at in retrospect… kind of an idiot’s guide to a bad break up of a long relationship – not a break up caused by something egregiously wrong with the relationship, but just not quite enough right to keep it going. Again, not my best work, but I figure somebody who just left a long-term relationship, who is still figuring out/scared about dating after a number of years, might find it helpful. If only as a guide of what not to do…
I will be mocking the previous author (me a number of months ago) in bold as I read along now.
I'm a little... no, make that a lot… confused by female behavior these days.
I'm 32 years old, and I've been single for over a year. Prior to this point, I've had three girlfriends over the past 11 years... one of 2+ years, one of about 4 months, and one of 7+ years One day I woke up, I was 32 and single, and at the moment I'm trying to figure out where the last 10 years went. Unfortunately, I just didn't know I was truly single until recently... I'll get into that in a bit. (Wow, who here is sympathetic for me at this point in the story? I think I’m deliberately looking for pity here…)
A little over a year ago, my girlfriend of 7+ years broke up with me because I wouldn't marry her. I'm not bitter about that decision, I didn't put up much of a fight - it was the right decision at the time. I know why I wasn't ready to marry her, there are multiple reasons (That’s right, apparently I thought someone would be interested by the stupid little minutiae of a defunct relationship. Feel free to read these reasons if you are also interested in A) Causing yourself pain, B) Watching paint dry, C) Danielle Steele novels, or D) You are currently battling insomnia):
1. She was intermittently insecure. Little problems, like her finances, would cause her to be very unhappy for days at a time. And there were lots of little problems to upset her. I realize that little problems can be important, but I generally don't sweat the stuff I can't fix on any given day. But I am empathetic - I found myself worrying about small stuff just because it upset her. Small stuff doesn't bother me at all, but my girlfriend being upset does... I generally view it as my job to make her happy. I was vicariously being upset by small stuff, and that really bothered me. Left to my own devices I’m a happy person, I’m pretty much always singing and cracking jokes. These days, I realize that some of this is my problem - to be with someone else, I need to learn not to have my emotions get caught up in my girlfriend’s problems. I just need to be there for her as support. (I love this… I believe this part, but it is also a deliberately calculated pose in case there are any single women reading this. All together now – awwwwwwwwwwwww!)
2. She used to intermittently get in fights with my friends/family. My friends and family are very opinionated, and sometimes they have pretty wild opinions. I completely admit, sometimes it is difficult for me not to get in a fight with them. I’m guessing in no small part due to the reasons listed in (1), every once in a while she would get upset because one of my friends/family disagreed with her. She didn't hide that fact very well, and she got into a few rather heated exchanges with my friends/family. This didn't happen very often, but the few times it did made me constantly worry about it happening again. Some of my friends/family are very difficult - for me to deal with them I have to control the environment... avoid potential problems. She was an X-factor, and it stressed me. I don't believe you should ever get in a fight with your significant others' friends/family. You can always walk away from a fight. Still, considering how difficult my family is, I may have had unrealistic expectations of her. I need to learn to deal with my family without feeling the need to control every little detail to avoid fights – and when they do get in fights I need to simply not care. That’s not her fault, its mine. My family is difficult – they will always get in fights – I need to learn to live with that. (Deliberate pose number 2 - How am I not beating the women off with a stick at this point?)
3. I wasn't ready to get married. I'm a PhD student in Neural Engineering at U of M - hopefully in my last year. My brother was in the process of killing himself through drugs/alcohol, and I was spending much of my time in Arizona trying to prevent it from happening. My grandmother's health was continuing to deteriorate... she was very old, and finally passed away, but it wasn't pretty at the end. There were a myriad of other significant problems with my family of similar import. PhD students by definition have to focus on themselves and their work; my focus was already being pulled away by a series of very serious family problems. My ex-girlfriend’s dad was a recovered alcoholic – her father made it on his own, so she felt I spent too much time on my brother. Eventually my brother overdosed and died, and I was frustrated my girlfriend didn’t completely support me in my efforts to prevent it. Again – a very hard situation, and perhaps I had very unrealistic expectations of my girlfriend. Everything had been so crazy the last two years - I do very much want to get married and have kids - it just wasn't the time. Now that’s the ordeal is finally over, I can start seriously thinking about marriage. (Hard to mock this part… it would be like making “Momma” jokes at the baby seal you’d just finished clubbing)
4. I believed she wanted to get married for the wrong reasons. She hadn't established an identity after college - she wasn't happy with her career and it bothered her unduly. She often felt embarrassed at the direction her career was taking, and she thought other people's opinions of her were lowered because of it. I was the safety net - I bailed her out of a number of financial problems. I felt she looked at getting married and becoming a "stay at home mother" as a way to justify her life to her friends and family. I wasn't sure she wanted to get married just because she loved me (which she did); it was instead her way of establishing a socially acceptable identity. To get married, you need to love yourself first. Until you do, I'm not sure you can truly love someone else. There is also the possibility, however, that I was just reading too much into things because I wasn’t ready to get married myself. (Oh, thank god that’s over… if you are still reading at this point, send me a message and I will buy you a beer)
I thought she could become the girl I wanted to be with forever - she had grown alot over the last 7 years, but she wasn't quite there yet. What do you do when you are 50/50 about marrying someone? After 7 years, my ex-girlfriend was tired of waiting - I understand. The last year and a half were strained; she felt she was auditioning for marriage and it stressed our relationship. She would cry, or come close to crying, every time the subject of marriage came up on television - you wouldn't believe how often it comes up. (This is kind of interesting here… most relationships end due to fighting/infidelity. There always seems to be an obvious reason to end it. What do you do when you are truly on the fence?)
Things became even more strained when my brother kept overdosing and I kept running to Arizona to help. She didn't want to go to dinner with my parents for my birthday because my parents only talked about my brother’s alcohol/drug problem. She called me up in AZ literally 5 minutes after I walked out of the hospital after seeing my brother in a coma for the first time. She gave an ultimatum - essentially “I need to know we’re getting married or I'm going to Minnesota to live with my brother for the summer.” I was furious; how the hell do you say that in that situation? (And the answer… wait for your significant other to shove you off the fence hard!)
I had come pretty close to proposing a few weeks before she uttered those words, but that ultimatum made me second guess myself. She apologized later… she always does. Occasionally she makes mistakes, but she's introspective; eventually she realizes the error and does genuinely try not to make the same mistake twice. I do respect and love that quality in her – but sometimes a first mistake is so egregious that it’s hard to give a second chance.
Her parting remark after she broke up with me was "If you ever decide you can't live without me, please come back." When we broke up, I did think we would get back together eventually. I felt she needed to be single for awhile to establish some more confidence in herself and her ability to stand on her own. She had been leaning on me too much during and after college, she needed to stand on her own two feet. Then we could be together as equals. (I think I was again kissing up to single women who might be reading up to this point. I had to deliberately put in the bit about “equals”… I do believe it, but it’s really pathetic to include it just to look open-minded)
Now is where the female confusion sets in. After the break-up, I made it explicitly clear I didn't want to have any contact. I did/do love her, and I didn't think either of us could handle the thought of the other dating. I flat out told her, I didn't want to know if she was dating someone else. Moreover, the whole point was she needed to be completely on her own to grow.
Despite that fact, for 6 months or so after the break up, I was talking to her on the phone once a week and seeing her twice a month. There was always something of mine to return, or some sort of problem to resolve. I never called her - I thought that would be unfair of me. My roommate thought she had a box of my stuff and was bringing it back one item at a time. Dropping off an item seemed to lead to a dinner and a movie together. This lasted until December - I found out later she really thought we were going to get back together in December. (I’ll ruin the surprise ending here… this is going to end badly… and yes, the Bruce Willis character is actually dead)
After December, my brother really went downhill, and I got distracted; but my ex-girlfriend and I still talked on the phone once a week. There was a brief period for a month and a half where we didn't see each other in person. Then we started seeing each other twice a month - going for a walk - seeing a movie and grabbing dinner. We had a great time… the only way I can describe it is that it was like coming home again.
She kept making comments - how much she missed me, how she still loved me, how she dated other guys but they didn't compare, etc. She called up at Easter almost crying; she wanted to come over and be with my family. She called up on the 1 year anniversary of our break up saying how much that thought upset her. Who the hell even remembers the one year anniversary of a break-up? I forget – is the one year break-up anniversary the diamond anniversary, or the toilet paper their house anniversary? (Alright… this still cracks me up. I wonder if I’ll get calls at the 5 and 10 year break-up anniversary.)
I had deliberately not called her to set up these outings - I thought I would be leading her on; but after my brother passed in March, I started calling her also. I seriously started to entertain thoughts of getting back together - knowing that if we did, it was to get married. My life had changed with my brother’s passing, I was the executor of his estate - I had to grow up. I spent a lot of time in Arizona with my sisters talking about their marriages and the work they put into them. I started to realize that love isn't about finding someone who is perfect – it’s about loving all of someone - including their flaws. (Oh dear God, how cloying. And we will teach all the little children of the world to hold hands and sing for world peace…)
I cancelled dates with other girls - I didn't want to lead them on, and I thought it would be unfair to my ex-girlfriend if I was seeing her and dating other people. I should note – our time together after December was innocent – we never even kissed. But the things she kept saying, and the fact she kept calling, had me convinced she wanted to get back together.
I was about to ask her thoughts on getting back together when things really got weird. We were supposed to go to a movie - she said she couldn’t go - she sounded upset. I asked her if everything was ok. She told me she had been dating a guy since December, they were supposed to move in together, and she just found out he was cheating on her.
You could have flown a 747 into my mouth as my jaw hit the floor (I think I was proud of this metaphor at the time). What the bloody hell?!?!?! I realize I originally said I didn’t want to know if she was dating another guy – I also said I wanted no contact - but she had to know she would have to tell me at some point. And the fact that she didn’t tell him she was seeing me twice a month, calling me once a week – and the things she said - I repeat …what the bloody hell? (Future me still says --- what the bloody hell?)
Apparently, she had been dating this guy for 7 months, and didn't tell me. What’s worse, she hadn't told him about me either. I let her know that I had been thinking about getting back together. She said she was confused, she didn't know what to do, and she needed time to think. She said she still loved me, that the other guy wasn’t the issue. She had established a new life, and she wasn’t sure if she could leave it; there’s irony for you – we break up because she hadn’t established her own life – and now that she had, it was too intertwined with her new boyfriend to leave him. (How about a cross between true irony and Alanis Morisette irony… otherwise known as Mor-onic?)
I gave her time - she moved in with the guy... but still said she needed more time to think (This is funny in retrospect… it’s like watching a horror movie… don’t go in the basement to check out the sound you idiot!). We talked the day after she moved in with him - she said she kept wishing she was moving in with me as she moved in, and that she only unpacked items that were easy to repack. I don't know what happened with the cheating thing exactly. Apparently he had been talking to girls on myspace, but nothing came of it - I don't know the details. Hell, I wouldn't blame the guy if he had cheated- she had been seeing her ex-boyfriend of 7 years - telling her ex she still loved him - and didn't breathe a word to her current boyfriend. (Run you crazy fool… run fast, run hard, but for the love of God… just Run!!!)
I know she was very confused – I do understand that. She left me hanging for about 2 months without a decision about if we would try to make our relationship work. Every time we talked - every e-mail - was “You’re amazing, I know I would be happy with you, I don’t know what’s stopping me.” or “Right now, I’m regretting my choice of not being with you.”
We have now cut off all contact, e-mail or otherwise – my idea.
Granted, this story is long as hell and rambling, so I doubt anyone has made it this far. But if you have, I’m curious – what the hell is going on here? Somebody get me a female to English dictionary. All I know is that her actions cannot bode well for her current relationship… I feel sorry for that guy. He has no clue how much his girlfriend is hiding in her head… information he seriously needs to know about their relationship.
Oddly, I feel sorry for her – I am a good guy – she’s missing out. More importantly, considering her actions, her relationship with that guy is doomed. I have no clue what strained logic justifies going to bed with your boyfriend every night while thinking of leaving him for someone else. I’m disappointed in her… I’d never of thought she’d violate someone’s trust to such an extent. She’s heading for more pain, and that makes me sad. Things have been hard for her, she’s very confused, and she’s made some very poor choices that can only lead to more hardship.
I’m trying to move on – I’m starting to date again. I still love her, and after spending half of my adult life with her, I wanted to try to make things work. But everyday, the thought of being with her fades a little more. Re-reading this story, I wonder why I’m being such a schmuck – why I’m moving on so slowly. I have to wonder why I still think a story about my ex-girlfriend, considering her behavior, was even worth the time to write it. Perhaps coming to that realization, was the only reason to write it.
Reading this months after it was written, I love the fact that I didn’t include her name once. Almost a Silence of the Lambs “It does not have a name” sort of pain going on here. I’m guessing I did it because she was still reading my blog surreptitiously at the time, and I didn’t want to upset her.